All eyes on Blues and Pies as Dogs ask the question, Freo’s top-four fate hangs in the balance

Should the Swans lose, the Dees could find themselves facing Collingwood, Fremantle, or even the Swans after all at the MCG; but even if they’re forced to head to Sydney, the reigning premiers look BACK.

Prediction: 2nd (3rd at start of round)

3. Sydney

15 wins, 6 losses, 128.3%

Plays: St Kilda @ Marvel Stadium, 4:40pm

If they win: 2nd, provided they beat St Kilda by approximately 54 points

If they lose: 4th if Collingwood loses; 5th if Collingwood win, 6th if Collingwood win and their percentage falls to lower than Brisbane’s 119.3%

The silver lining for the Swans out of Melbourne’s thumping win over Brisbane is that, with a percentage gap of 9 over the Lions, falling to sixth is now extremely unlikely.

The bad news is that they’ll now need to thump St Kilda on Sunday to retake a home qualifying final against the Demons; knowing how much they’ll need to win by isn’t so much of an advantage anymore.

At the very least, a Swans win will seal up third; but a loss will see them leapfrogged by Fremantle, who defeated GWS, and Collingwood, who are even-money odds to defeat Carlton.

The Swans still have the top four in their own hands; but their path to a premiership just got a little tougher.

Prediction: 3rd (2nd at start of round)

4. Fremantle

15 wins, 1 draw, 6 losses, 117%

Defeated GWS by 20 points

Best-case scenario: 3rd if Sydney AND Collingwood lose, 4th if Sydney OR Collingwood lose, 5th if both win

Worst-case scenario: 5th

And breathe, Freo fans.

The Dockers made mighty tough work of it, trailing GWS by 31 points early in the second term, but they eventually did enough for a 20-point victory that keeps their top-four chances alive.

Had they scored one extra point against Richmond in that draw, they’d now be locked into a double chance – but as it stands, they’ll be nervously watching Collingwood’s clash with Carlton and Sydney’s with St Kilda on Sunday.

If either the Magpies or Swans lose, the Dockers will face Geelong in a blockbuster qualifying final at the MCG. And we all know their record against the Cats in qualifying finals.

Prediction: 4th

5. Brisbane

15 wins, 7 losses, 119.3%

Defeated by Melbourne by 58 points

Best-case scenario: 5th if Collingwood lose

Worst-case scenario: 6th if Collingwood win

Regardless of where they wind up when Round 23 concludes, the Lions’ embarrassing loss to Melbourne on Friday night has taken an axe to their premiership credentials.

From dreaming of a home qualifying final heading into that match, the very best the Lions can hope for now is to sneak into fifth, and face one of Carlton or the Western Bulldogs with the double chance.

Should Collingwood defeat Carlton, however, it will mean Richmond at the Gabba in an elimination final.

Yikes.

Prediction: 5th

6. Collingwood

15 wins, 6 losses, 104.4%

Plays: Carlton @ the MCG, Sunday 3:20pm

If they win: 3rd if Sydney lose, 4th if Sydney win

If they lose: 6th

The Pies’ percentage is basically one fewer win at this point, which makes my job a lot easier. So thanks, narrow wins!

The Magpies head to the MCG on Sunday already knowing half the stakes at play: they are guaranteed top four ahead of Brisbane and Fremantle.

They will also know if Richmond have, as expected, got the job done against Essendon to lock in seventh, or whether losing to Carlton will see the Pies face the Blues again in week one of the final. Either would make the city of Melbourne just about unbearable for the next week and a half.

The Pies have more to gain with a win than any other side in the eight, and just as much to lose. Beat the Blues, and a shock top-four finish, a precious double chance, and a likely shot at Geelong at the ‘G, is their reward. Lose, and she gets ugly.

Over to you, Craig McRae.

Prediction: 6th

7. Richmond

13 wins, 1 draw, 8 losses, 121.6%

Defeated Essendon by 66 points

Only scenario: 7th

After their draw with Freo and incredible losses to Gold Coast and North Melbourne, the Tigers needed to win three of their last four to be locked into September. Tick, tick, and tick, and one more win over Essendon in the final round for good measure..

Now, it’s all about seeing whether they play Brisbane or Collingwood in an elimination final – a Magpies win over Carlton would see them head to the Gabba, while a Carlton triumph would set up a mouthwatering rematch of the 2018 preliminary final at the MCG.

But whoever they play, the truth is this: nobody in their right mind is going to want to play Richmond this September.

Prediction: 7th

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

8. Western Bulldogs

12 wins, 10 losses, 108.9%

Defeated Hawthorn by 23 points

Best-case scenario: 8th if Carlton loses

Worst-case scenario: 9th

It was far less comfortable than Dogs fans would have been hoping for; but ultimately, Luke Beveridge’s men leave Tasmania having done exactly what they needed to do.

For starters, four points was a must, but by winning by 23 points, the Dogs’ percentage moved marginally ahead of the Blues’, meaning Carlton will need to beat Collingwood (or draw) to play in September.

All eyes are on the MCG.

Prediction: 9th

9. Carlton

12 wins, 9 losses, 108.8%

Plays: Collingwood @ the MCG, Sunday 3:20pm

If they win: 8th

If they lose: 9th

The Blues had one foot in September when Charlie Curnow gave them an eight-point lead in the dying minutes against Melbourne.

Instead, long-suffering fans will have to wait until at least 3:30pm on Sunday to know whether their nine-year finals drought is at an end.

For starters, the Blues will be donning brown and gold early on Sunday, hoping Hawthorn can take down the Bulldogs and get them in without needing to lift a finger. (Woo-hoo! Default!)

If the Bulldogs win by more than about three goals, removing their current 0.9 percentage disadvantage, then it becomes simple for the Blues: beat the Pies and they’re in, lose and they’re gone.

But if the Dogs win in a tight game, then the Blues can still go down to the Magpies and squeak into the finals – but by gee, the lines will be painstakingly tight.

Ultimately, the Blues showed tremendous ticker and spirit to come so close to Melbourne in Round 22, and with one last chance to get the four points they needed, I’m backing them to get it done.

Prediction: 8th

10. St Kilda

11 wins, 10 losses, 100.1%

Plays: Sydney @ Marvel Stadium, Sunday 4:40pm

If they win: 8th if Carlton get mauled by Collingwood or a top-eight team is found guilty of a club-wide doping program, 9th if one of those things happen, 10th if neither of those things happen

If they lose: 10th

The Saints’ percentage gap to Carlton sits at 8.7, meaning to make finals, they’d need to see Collingwood beat the Blues by 70-odd points, then do the same to the Swans.

Yeah. It ain’t happening.

Prediction: 10th

Dejected Carlton players walk from the ground after losing to Melbourne. (Photo by Darrian Traynor/Getty Images)

The Roar’s predicted top eight

1. Geelong (18-4)
2. Melbourne (16-6)
3. Sydney (16-6)
4. Fremantle (15-1-6)
5. Brisbane (15-7)
6. Collingwood (15-7)
7. Richmond (13-1-8)
8. Carlton (13-9)

The Roar’s predicted Finals Week One

Qualifying Final: Geelong vs Fremantle

Qualifying Final: Melbourne vs Sydney

Elimination Final: Brisbane vs Carlton

Elimination Final: Collingwood vs Richmond